« GM Bails on Rail | Main | Jakarta Governor Wants to Mandate CNG Use in City »
Biodiesel or SVO?
12 January 2005
Although biodiesel is drawing increasing attention from automakers, policymakers and farmers, there is another biofuel that can be used in diesel engines: straight vegetable oil, or SVO.
The two approaches, although apparently similar, are operationally and philosophically quite different. Broadly stated, you can either modify (refine) plant oil to create biodiesel to run in an unmodified diesel engine, or you can modify an engine system to allow it to use unaltered vegetable oil.
Journey to Forever, a terrific resource on multiple aspects of sustainability, puts it this way:
Does the SVO option work? Yes—IF you go about it the right way. It’s not quite that simple a choice. For one thing, if you want to use waste vegetable oil, which is often free, you’re going to have to process it anyway, though less so than to make biodiesel. And it still might not be a very good fuel.
The main problem is that vegetable oil is much more viscous (thicker) than conventional diesel fuel. It must be heated (thinned) so that it can be properly atomised by the fuel injectors. If it’s not properly atomised, it won’t burn properly, forming deposits on the injectors and in the cylinder head, leading to poor performance, higher emissions, and reduced engine life.
Nonetheless, experience is showing that SVO systems are a practical proposition with a lot of advantages to offer, not least of all that using SVO can be cheaper than turning it into biodiesel and uses less energy than making biodiesel does.
But you have to be willing to take on the modifications. For those inclined to a D-I-Y project, there are a number of resources and kits available.
I will start including SVO on the site, including product news and lifecycle and emissions studies.
A few SVO links and online resources
Neoteric Biofuels—established in 2000
Elsbett—one of the best established European conversion companies
Biodiesel Discussion Forum—follow the links to the SVO forum
January 12, 2005 in Biodiesel, D-I-Y, SVO | Permalink | Comments (27) | TrackBack (2)
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/22062/1665774
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Biodiesel or SVO?:
» Biodiesle versus SVO from B100 Fuel, living on BioDiesel
Green Car Congress is on top of it again: Green Car Congress: Biodiesel or SVO? Good analysis comparing BioDiesel to Straight Vegitable Oil. I still like Biodiesel. Less potential problems with clogging and no heating required, use it straight in... [Read More]
Tracked on Jan 18, 2005 1:32:49 PM
» Re: Question about veggie oil from tribe.net: www.greencarcongress.com
I found this on http://www.greencarcongress.com/2005/01/biodiesel_or_sv.html
... [Read More]
Tracked on Jul 24, 2005 11:13:24 PM
Comments
To see a WVO conversion being installed, and to learn how to do one yourself, see http://www.green-trust.org/wiki/index.php?title=VeggieBenz
Posted by: Steve Spence | Jan 13, 2005 6:03:01 AM
WVO = Waste Vegetable Oil
SVO = Straight Vegetable Oil
Posted by: Mike | Jan 13, 2005 8:09:01 AM
Just FYI, SVO/WVO have different implications as far as emissions when compared to biodiesel. For example, the combustion in a vehicle running SVO/WVO releases acrolein, a known carcinogen, but this is absent from biodiesel as a result of the chemical differences.
This is just one example, but people thinking about WVO/SVO instead of biodiesel should do their research if the motivation is environmentalism...
Posted by: jamie | Jan 13, 2005 1:16:35 PM
Sir,
We are the leading promoter of jatropha in India for biodiesel production.
Can we use jatropha oil directly without going for transesterification process?
Sir, since we are promoting farming for the biofuel , if SVO OF JATROPHA CAN BE DIRECTLY USED FOR RURAL MACHINARIES it would be a great help in success of our project as economic viability would be enhanced.
kindly explain the process of utilisation of SVO or modification in vehicles required
regards,
abhi
centre for jatropha promotion
http://www.jatrophaworld.org
Posted by: ABHISHEK | Jan 14, 2005 9:54:53 AM
sir,
we r doing our project on biodiesel(direct blending)can u help to our project.
Thanking you.
Posted by: saravanan | Feb 28, 2005 1:14:19 AM
Jamie,
can you point me to some more info on this acrolein thing. I'm looking at what levels are produced and at what levels is it really toxic. Their are many things that in high levels can cause cancer but in small amounts do not, so knowing these points is fairly important.
Posted by: Tony O | Mar 3, 2005 12:22:44 AM
sir,
i am engg. student , trying to use jatropha as a fuel in automotive cars directly without Transesterification process . I am having difficulties in doing this. Can you help me.
Posted by: abhijit vasant pisal | Mar 7, 2005 6:56:19 AM
Can one safely blend used vegetable oil with commercially available diesel fuel with no negative effects and up to what proportions. I have in mind 30% veg oil to 70% commercial diesel. This in a normally aspirated diesel engine? This vehicle runs in subtropical areas where no temperatures below zero are encountered.
Posted by: Garth Richardson | May 3, 2005 2:40:10 PM
The acrolein issue was a red herring. It was discovered burning wvo on a bunsen burner in a lab by folks who have never touched a diesel engine. WVO emissions are very similar to biodiesel emissions. No, you cannot mix vegetable oil with diesel without heat in most engines and environments. Damage to the injector pump and injectors usually follows. If you want to run wvo, do it right with two tanks and heated oil.
Posted by: Steve Spence | Jun 10, 2005 4:04:35 PM
sir,
can u tell me what is transesterification? can u tell hou to convert jatropa oil to bio diesel in detail.
thanking you sir,
Posted by: niranjan | Sep 7, 2005 3:49:32 AM
sir,
i am an engineering student want to do a project on the perfrmance of jatropa bio diesel. could u please explain about esterification of jatropa oil
thanking u sir
Posted by: laxmankumar | Sep 24, 2005 1:01:31 AM
Students:
You can find all the information about biodiesel and WVO in the journeytoforever link up there. Dig thru that site and read it carefully. Dont be lazy to do research study is not always the case of copy n paste :)
Posted by: rexis | Sep 29, 2005 12:14:36 AM
Can anyone one give me a link and/or info comparing emissions outputs of a properly implemented SVO system compared to that of a modern diesel engine?
THANKS!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: Schuyler Spears | Oct 2, 2005 1:27:25 PM
sir
i am engg. student,working on Jatropa as a Bio-Diesel to find out the performance of I.C.Engine. How should i carry the test & on which point i should be
concentrated
thanking u
Posted by: ajit | Oct 4, 2005 9:20:47 PM
What are the modifications required in an IC engine if we use jatropha bio-diesel as the fuel.Incase if optimum modifications be made will that be efficient?
kindly clarify me at the earliest.
Posted by: vijay prakash | Oct 17, 2005 1:48:31 AM
sir i am intersting to make biodiesel. i want some help to making biodiesel. how can use SVO to make biodiesel. thankyou.
Posted by: naveen | Oct 23, 2005 8:57:05 PM
Recently I was turned onto the idea of WVO/SVO over BD... And this ELSBETT single tank seems the least complicated and most assured of the fuel heating options. However, since it is assured for SVO only, the question becomes, where can i get SVO? Do i need to go to a public-access 'warehouse' store to find cheap SVO? [costco, smart'n'final, walmart =( ]
Posted by: Alex | Oct 25, 2005 11:48:33 AM
sir,
i am mba student.i would like to start up business in biodiesel.kindly guide me to proceed further.i am in kerala.
expecting favourable reply.
Sincerely,
Davish
Posted by: davish | Oct 29, 2005 9:49:53 AM
Kay, I don't think anyone who has converted diesel engines here in North America or in the U.K. knows what jatropha is. Nor how one would go about making biodiesel from it, or convert an engine to run on SJO (straight jatropha oil) . All I can think of is to follow the links at the top of the page. These will lead you to the conversions necessary for biodiesel from vegetable oil and for running SVO. Try the same processes using this jatropha stuff instead of vegetable oil and see how it works!
Posted by: Luc Godin | Nov 20, 2005 1:20:02 AM
I have the same question as Alex about the SVO conversions. I just got my Mercedes & am leaning toward making biodiesel of WVO since you're not supposed to put WVO in the converted cars. And then I wouldn't have to worry about all that heating & injector angles & filters & stuff. Diesels are strange to me as it is. I just learned what glow plugs are! So, am I understanding correctly that if you want to use WVO, making biodiesel would be a better choice?
Posted by: Susan | Nov 21, 2005 4:46:06 PM
sir,
I
am an engg student intrested in doing projet on jatropa oil as a fuel on the performance of ic engines.so please provide information on this.
Posted by: raghujoshi | Feb 9, 2006 12:25:49 AM
hi,
i m doing project on bio diesel using jatropha as fuel, so it would be very kind of you if you tell us whether we can use it directly or not.
Posted by: soumyadeep saha | Feb 22, 2006 10:43:53 PM
I am building a web site that will advertise who is selling biodiesel, I will not be associated with biodiesel.org I repeat not associating this website with biodiesel org.
If you want free advertising call me 954 458 5220
www.wesellbiodiesel.com
Space is limited
I intend to make this the #1 website for biodiesel info and retailers in the US.
ANY FEEDSTOCK USER IS WELCOME "NOT JUST THE SOY FARMERS"
I am not a manufacturer or producer, I am an advertiser!!!
PASS THE WORD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: David Occhiuzzo | Jul 20, 2006 12:00:54 PM
I am building a web site that will advertise who is selling biodiesel, I will not be associated with biodiesel.org I repeat not associating this website with biodiesel org.
If you want free advertising call me 954 458 5220
www.wesellbiodiesel.com
Space is limited
I intend to make this the #1 website for biodiesel info and retailers in the US.
ANY FEEDSTOCK USER IS WELCOME "NOT JUST THE SOY FARMERS"
I am not a manufacturer or producer, I am an advertiser!!!
PASS THE WORD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted by: David Occhiuzzo | Jul 20, 2006 12:00:58 PM
sir,
I am doing project on producing SVO from jatropha. I get difficulity while trying to modify our SVO product. how can we produce SVO directly low viscous then before? we have modified our diesel machine to be compatible of using SVO with convertion kit. It takes the heat of radiator to get contact with SVO to make SVO become less viscous. but it will be great if the product output from reactor have low viscosity. could anyone suggest me what should I do?
Thanks Lot...
-arief-
Posted by: Ahmad Arief | Dec 17, 2006 6:55:48 PM
Sir,
I want to know that , though for using Biodiesel no major modifications are required but still whether we can modify the engine for its better performence.? for this what are the steps to be taken.? In modern scenerio what are asspects of biodiesel.? Plz reply....
Posted by: Ankur | Jul 19, 2007 2:58:32 AM
Actually interesting site. Thanks to you for info. You are good that, remain so. 1288769312
Posted by: pay per click | Aug 4, 2007 11:45:42 PM
