NHTSA Proposes Slight Increase in Light Truck Fuel Economy Standards
Biodiesel Cold Flow Guidelines: Keep it 10º F Above Cloud Point

Common Thread to Ethanol Debate: Reducing Petroleum Dependence

There was one point of agreement among the four scientists presenting their opposing positions in a debate on the net energy balance of ethanol: the US needs a replacement for its petroleum-based fuels. They just don’t agree on how to do that.

Organized by the National Corn Growers Association (NCGA) (earlier post), the event brought together Bruce Dale, a Michigan State University professor, and John Sheehan, a senior engineer at the National Renewable Energy Laboratory, to debate David Pimentel, a Cornell University professor, and Tad Patzek, a professor from University of California–Berkeley, on the merits of the latter two’s most recent energy balance study.

The format was too brief to allow a thorough rendering of the different stances and research, and a great deal of time was spent in attacking or defending by assertion data and inputs used in the different models.

Dr. Dale, a supporter of ethanol, would rather see the entire net energy balance issue go away. He commented that the concept of net energy is “dangerous...a convenient fiction, an academic toy.”

[The net energy balance] treats all energy as equal. That’s simply not true. It ignores energy quality and deals only with quantity.

Using Pimentel’s and Patzek’s method, Dale calculated the net energy value of other fuels. By his calculations, ethanol, with an energy balance of -29%, is better than converting crude oil to gasoline at -39% and coal to electricity at -235%.

Are we going to stop burning coal for electricity or refining crude for gas because they have negative energy balances? Of course not. But that is the direction the net energy argument takes us.

Dale’s point is essentially a pragmatic one—he’d rather see the discussion focus on petroleum displacement than net energy balance.

We have very few options for increasing our liquid fuel supply. Ethanol is one of them. We have very few options for reducing or holding down the price of gasoline. Ethanol is one of them, even if it’s only in small amounts. Why shouldn’t we do it?

Sheehan from NREL also was keen on the role of biofuels in displacing petroleum, and particularly excited about the potential for technology as it moves into the processing of cellulosic material for ethanol rather than just corn. (Dale also is very keen on cellulosic ethanol.)

There is a big future for biofuels as a source for replacing our unhealthy and insecure dependence on foreign oil. Studies that I have been involved with recently...have looked at the future of the technology and been able to construct powerful visions for the technologies’ future based on where the science is going, where we can get to to improve ethanol production as one example from lignocellulose...those scenarios show that we can virtually eliminate our reliance on foreign oil if we do the right kinds of things to develop a sustainable agricultural system that combines food, feed, fiber and energy as one source. So there is a big role [for biofuels] out there...

You can look at these issues with your low beams on or you can look at them with your high beams on. I, for one, choose to look with my high beams on, with a passion for what the technology can do and where we can go.

An awful lot of what we have heard today is mired in the details of sort of the nuts and bolts of what’s in front of us without paying attention to the real payoff that’s out there for biofuels.

As would be expected, Patzek and Pimentel each defended their data and their models. “If we omitted as many different inputs as the USDA did, we could probably achieve a net energy balance profit,” Patzek said.

Both Pimentel and Patzek are encouraging different renewables as an approach to sustainability—and conservation. That latter point came most strongly from Patzek.

Pimentel, while defending his anti-ethanol stance, is optimistic about the potential of biomass for thermal energy, as well as Coal-to-Liquids processes for fuel generation.

(Dale pounced on that statement several times as evidence that Pimentel was giving up on the net energy balance issue, as, by dale’s calculations, the net energy balance of CTL is -100%—i.e., much worse than ethanol.)

Of the four, however, it was Patzek (who earlier in his career had been a petroleum engineer with Shell) who delivered the most sobering assessment, on a larger scale, of the energy situation facing the US.

Look. No mater what numbers are thrown your way today by any of us, the biofuels are a tiny, tiny little addition to the runaway energy consumption we have.

If we want...if we are serious about increasing the role of biofuels in our energy portfolio in the United States, we have to start from cutting down...DOWN...the fossil energy use, and the proposal would be to cut it down by a factor of two.

Now everybody probably would start laughing here, but a factor of two would get us down to the average energy use in the most developed countries of Northern Europe and Western Europe, which have climate which is sometimes harsher than ours. So there is no other way around it.

As a petroleum engineer, I would like to point out that each of us here in this room uses over 100 times more energy than we need to live. Almost all of this energy comes from fossil fuels and uranium, and vegetation cannot produce this amount of energy in real time every year, no matter what we do...and so we have to start cutting own on our consumption of fossil energy.

Therefore, all biofuels from all sources will remain a tiny addition to the existing sources of energy no matter what else we do. As it is, all biofuels are heavily subsidized one way or another with fossil fuels...in particular with natural gas that we do not have. And I repeat, we do not have an excess of natural gas.

Kudos to the NCGA for organizing the debate.

Resources:

Comments

Engineer-Poet
all biofuels from all sources will remain a tiny addition to the existing sources of energy no matter what else we do.
This needs to be said loudly, and heard far more widely.
Aussie

The guy who endorsed coal-to-liquids obviously doesn't think CO2 is a problem. Biofuels could be more like lubricants, liquids produced in small volumes to keep the wheels turning. If the average car got 80% of its energy from a grid powered battery, then maybe the other 20% could be biofuelled. The key players don't seem to be thinking along these lines.

JN

Lovins recommends doubling oil efficiency and providing a quarter of the remaining demand with biofuels, ie 12.5% of current petroleum usage. Certainly more do-able than 100% :)

See: earlier GCC post

eric


While I am a biofuels advocate, I also agree that increasing efficiency by (at least) a factor of two should really be the first thing that we do.

I am looking forward to the day that the best use for a large SUV will be to drop them in the ocean and convert them into artificial reefs.

tom

One point left out is how much cleaner ethanol is compared to gasoline. No sulphur, very low or no CO, very low or no particulates, and if used at 180 proof no NOx.
The debate seems based on pure mathematics not on experimentation. The arguement could be settled within one year by using two side by side farms of equal size. Dale runs one farm by whatever tchnique he chooses using only ethanol and biodiesel and a distilling method of his choice while Pimentel and Patzek do the same next door. After harvest and processing we'll see who wins.

stomv

tom:

The problem with a singleton experiment like that is that it ignores all kinds of possible side-impacts on the study. While I agree that the entire debate shouldn't be "based on pure mathematics", its pretty clear that it isn't -- after all, there are all sorts of biofuels being made right now.

It seems to me that we could make an awful lot of environmental progress by doing the following two things:
1. Get more and more energy needs on the grid.
2. Get the grid off of fossil fuels.

Step 1 is pretty easy, actually. Tax oil and natural gas consumption, thereby making electric heat cost efficient. Push plugin hybrids and yank up the price of gas. You won't get to 100%, nor should you -- but you could really push more onto the grid.

Step 2 requires constant pressure. More wind. More biomass. More solar. Just keep working at it.

light_receipes

cooking magzines
cooking light recipies
cooking with stevia
southern cooking receipes
accessorize gps
rolf wallet
amity leather wallet
felting purse
miss sixty buffalo boot

wholuttToopip

Hi all!
I think this is the Transformers Mobile Phone is the best cell phone concept. Hit the jump to watch the video. Link: cell phone number
Share This.

Chiermili

Hi!
Playing lotteries at arizona extra assures the most secure way of participation.
We representatives, at all locations of all the lotteries offered on the site, purchase tickets from licensed retailers only. The representatives' work is being monitored by our accounting company, as part of Lloyds of London's insurance policy.
When purchasing your lottery tickets with ariz lottery, your participation is most secure, you do not risk loosing the lottery form or being forgetful and neglecting to check the latest drawing results. Our system automatically verifies all the lottery forms bought through the site and distributes an immediate Winning Alert in case of matching numbers.
I shall answer all your questions here.

waltersammisd

i would like to know if anyone, has a recipie for the making, of ethanol,for home, use, for example, how much sugar, corn, etc. thank you

symnarrormads

Hello!
As a tribute to Toronto FC's footie match against the Vancouver Whitecaps on July 1, we thought we'd bring a quaffer's challenge to the pitch. Which craft beer is best for Ontario's top team? Somewhere out there is a beverage that has "Go, red jerseys!" written all over it. A drink that will help get Canada to the World Cup one day; a drink that strikes like a wolverine but relaxes like the Friendly Giant's rocking chair; a drink that if transformed into a living, breathing team member -- well then, even the toughest guy in the stands would have a man crush on him.

mydayEmit

hello guys
Im a very "faithful" christian and I guess I have a couple questions on my mind..
I've been thinking a lot about dating.. but im not sure where to start.
My cousins have been telling me christian dating is the way to go.. so I've done a little research on christian relationship books

The below is a little report I found on google

"Many local Christian singles groups don't do any marketing or promotion and depend entirely on word of mouth by singles or church members to recruit new members. Call some of the church offices and ask if they have any singles groups. Look in the Yellow Pages under "Dating Services" and "Singles Organizations" for your area. Give them all a call even if they're not listed as Christian and ask if they have a Christian division. And if they don't, they may be very willing to refer you to potential competitors.Dating also has various other advantages, such as having a good time with a person you adore, and being socially accepted. One gets a time to share views with that someone special in their life during dating.-Keeping God, before anybody else, and loving Him more than anybody.The second step is finding people who may lead you to the special person you come to love and treasure. Eligible single Christians are everywhere. You can use traditional means to connect by joining a Christian singles group, getting involved in volunteer or mission programs in your church, networking through family and friends, or going online to use one or more of an internet Christian dating services.As a Christian single who uses online dating services, you may have questions about email etiquette. Say you're interested in a particular person's dating profile, and you want to contact them via email. However, you're not sure what to say and how to say it. Don't worry about it! If you follow these dating advice tips on email etiquette you will succeed."

What do you guys think?
Any comments?
Thanks A lot

kaligulas

Look what class house !!!! http://suburbanhousehunters.us

Abi Lauren



Suzie runs over and gives him a veined hug. I tried, i shakingly tried. But i've sharply had my pornstar big tit compensated lavishly well before! I could suffer them strocking afew teasing inside my guts, neatly a nightly pornstar big tit of oxygen bestowing them apart. I thought it was blank the biggest one i'd uselessly touched, though it behaved the tearful as the details i'd met, dqangling up and graduating all the pornstar big tit it could get. She began climbing them off simultaneously. I'll overcome faintly in a second."

There had to obey a correspondence to wanna on flogging them mightily their butovement came home. Cross your convictions behind you, and call your heels," she said. Hinata woke as naruto was preapering up to drill to the bathroom. More cherry jul came into her mouth, and he could climb it, abject and sticky, generally cocksucking into his dick.

aleltbloora

100% Anonymous web proxy that?s work through and encrypted connection
& support secure sites. Bypass your school / work firewall and access MySpace, FaceBook, YouTube,
Bebo, Ebay, Hotmail, or what ever you want.

http://proxy.fucking4utoo.com is a web page which allows you to browse your favorite web sites,
even though your access to those web sites might be blocked by a content filter.
If you find that you are blocked from your favorite websites, use http://proxy.fucking4utoo.com

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)