Chinese Researchers Show Enhanced Hydrogen Production from Corn Stover by Anaerobic Fermentation
26 June 2009
Researchers at Zhengzhou University, China, have shown the enhanced production of hydrogen from pretreated corn stalk biomass by mixed culture using manure from the lesser panda as the source of the hydrogen-producing bacteria. The study is reported in Issue 54 (8)the Chinese Science Bulletin, a journal co-sponsored by the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the National Natural Science Foundation of China. The annual yield of natural cellulosic biomass in China exceeds 0.7 billion tons, in which the amount of corn stalk is around 220 million tons.
The maximum cumulative H2 yield of 176 ml/g-TS (total solids) and H2 production rate (14.5 ml/g-TS h-1) were obtained at pH 5.5, 36 °C by treating a substrate of 15 g/L. The hydrogen content in the resultant biogas was 57.2% and there was no significant methane gas observed.
The team has also shown the production of cellulosic ethanol of 234.1 mg/g-total volatile solid (TVS) and of hydrogen (66.9 mL/g-TVS) in a two-stage process from enzymatic-treated cornstalk. (Pan et al., 2009). In this study, the team used dairy manure for hydrogen production in this two stage process; the hydrogen was produced from the effluent of the first, cellulosic ethanol stage by mixed culture.
Based on prior work that had shown hydrogen production potential of 89.2 mL/g-TS using microbes from cow manure and 109.0 mL/g-TS using microbes from lesser panda manure, the researchers opted to use lesser panda manure in the hydrogen study reported in the Chinese Science Bulletin.
During the optimal period of H2 production, the ORP (oxidation-reduction potential) values stayed in the lower level ranging from 445 mV to 455 mV. The results, said the researchers, show that the bio-pretreatment of the raw materials played a vital role in the effective conversion of corn stalk by mixed culture.
The researchers examined the influences of three pretreatment methods on the yields of soluble saccharides (SS) and H2:
Dilute acid pretreatment: The yields of soluble saccharides (SS) and H2 were significantly dependent on the acid types and acid concentration. The maximum SS yields of 212 mg/g-TS at lactic acid concentration of 0.4%; 343 mg/g-TS at HCl concentration of 1.0%; and 350 mg/g-TS at H2SO4 concentration of 2.0% were observed. Maximum H2 yields of 125 mL/g-TS at 0.4% lactic acid 0.4%; 129 mL/g-TS at 1.0% HCl concentration; 151 mL/g-TS at H2SO4 1.5% concentration were observed.
With further increases in acid concentration, the trend was reversed. The results are consistent with the team’s previous studies, in which higher anion concentrations of Cl- and SO42- inhibited heavily the growth of the hydrogen-producing bacteria and led to the decrease of bio-hydrogen production capacity.
Acid-enzyme coupling pretreatment: The anaerobic atmosphere is beneficial to the enzymatic hydrolysis of corn stalk and the hydrogen production. The yields of SS and H2 increased rapidly with the increase in the enzyme dosage from 348 mg/g-TS and 134 mL/g-TS at 1.1 IU/g to maximum 468 mg/g-TS and 165 mL/g-TS at 17.6 IU/g.
Solid bio-pretreatment: The process of the bio-pretreatment was accompanied by the generation of lactic acid, the microbe additive loading significantly effected the yields of SS and lactic acid in bio-pretreated corn stalk. An increase of the SS yield could be observed in the range of dosage 2.5 g/kg to 7.5 g/kg, the maximum SS yield of 212 mg/g-TS occurred at dosage 7.5 g/kg, and then with further increase in microbe additive dosage the trend was reversed.
Furthermore, the mechanism studies of hydrogen production from pretreated corn stalk indicated that the enhanced H2 yield related to the direct bio-degradation of the hemi-cellulose and cellulose besides the contribution of the generated SS and lactic acid in the bio-pretreated corn stalk during the bio-hydrogen fermentation.
The verification tests were performed in a 5-liter continuously stirred anaerobic bioreactor (CSABR) with 3-liter mixture at fixed bio-pretreated corn stalk of 15 g/L, pH 5.5, 36 °C and HRT for 10 h.
The maximal H2 yield, H2 content and H2 production rate was observed at 175.6 mL/g-TS, 57.2% and 14.5 mL/g-TS•h-1, respectively. During the optimal bio-hydrogen production period, the ORP value stayed in the range of -445 mV to -455 mV, which was consistent with that in previous reports.
During H2 fermentation progresses, butyric acid, acetic acid and alcohol as main metabolic by-products were left at the reactor, during which butyrate and acetate accounted for about 70-80% of VFAs, and there was no significant methane observed in the CSABR. The CSABR operated steadily for 170 h with higher H2 yield and lower H2 partial pressure level, and the pH value could be easily adjusted by online control system, the researchers said.
Resources
Xing Y, Ma H C, Fan Y T, et al. (2009) Cellulose-hydrogen production from corn stalk biomass by anaerobic fermentation. Chinese Sci Bull, 54(8): 1434-1441, doi: 10.1007/s11434-009-0147-x
Pan CM, Zhang ML, Fan YT, Xing Y, Hou HW. (2009) Production of Cellulosic Ethanol and Hydrogen from Solid-State Enzymatic Treated Cornstalk: A Two-Stage Process. J. Agric. Food Chem., 57(7):2732-2738 doi: 10.1021/jf803779b
Great. Now we're going to have to invade China to take control of their lesser panda scat natural resources.
Posted by: Nixon | 26 June 2009 at 02:30 PM
Nixon:
That may not be such a good idea. China may not agree and fight to keep their lesser Panda manure.
Why not buy this natural extract instead even if you have to borrow more from China or print more dollars to do it?
If the going gets much more financially tight, USA could go Chapter 11 and get off the hook for about 15% to 20%. A one hundred ++ trillion dollar debt could become a mere $15 trillion IOU.
Posted by: HarveyD | 26 June 2009 at 02:58 PM
The reason they use the lesser panda manure is that it could claim to be protecting scarce resource.
Posted by: Peace Hugger | 26 June 2009 at 03:54 PM
It because of the Democrats, we have a Panda Poo Gap!
Posted by: dursun | 26 June 2009 at 06:50 PM
The Chinese have long spent a lot of money on all things Panda, and will undoubtedly continue to do so - which is why it's not surprising the researchers are using Panda poo instead of some other poo from a more common animal. A little GCC research will reveal the US is way ahead of the world in cellulosic biofuel research. Personally, I like the idea of Miscanthus pellets, grown in former tobacco plantations & elsewhere, as fuel in power plants that would otherwise burn coal (actively being researched & developed in Kentucky and some other places) and transitioning away from the ICE.
Posted by: ejj | 26 June 2009 at 07:35 PM
Not to sidetrack the party, but you want to create the H2 at or close to the point of use, storing and transporting it are problems.
If you have renewable methane piped to fueling stations and you reform it there, H2 might be possible for cars some day at a reasonable price. Then if you have adsorbants where you can run at lower pressure, that would help too.
Posted by: SJC | 27 June 2009 at 09:46 AM