Toyota researchers show superior performance for tin anode for Mg-ion batteries with conventional electrolytes
14 November 2012
Researchers at the Toyota Research Institute of North America (TRINA) have developed an insertion-type tin (Sn) anode material for use in a magnesium-ion (Mg-ion) battery (earlier post) that shows superior operating voltages and capacity. In a paper accepted for publication in the RSC journal Chemical Communications, they report showing that a Sn anode could attain higher capacities (903 mAh g-1) and lower Mg2+ insertion/extraction voltages (+ 0.15/0.20 V) than previously reported using a bismuth (Bi) material (384 mAh g-1, + 0.23/0.32 V).
They confirmed the material’s performance in rechargeable Mg-ion batteries by coupling it with a Mo6S8 cathode in a conventional battery electrolyte—that necessary compatibility and cyclability being an important result, they noted. The use of Sn as an insertion-type anode would allow for the evaluation of future, high voltage/capacity Mg-ion battery cathodes using conventional battery electrolytes, they concluded.
The introduction of electric vehicles (EVs) and plug-in hybrid vehicles (PHVs) via the use of such alternative technologies (e.g. batteries) as stand-alone or tandem energy sources is slowly revolutionizing the face of the automobile industry. However, while batteries are a cleaner alternative to fossil fuels, concerns over their long range performance in automobiles have hampered their widespread use. Hence, high performance battery systems which meet automobile energy use, and especially space requirements, remain paramount in establishing the next generation of EVs and PHVs.
In this regard, multivalent battery systems like rechargeable magnesium (Mg), calcium and aluminum-ion batteries are garnering more interest as candidate post-lithium (Li) systems. Mg, being divalent and denser, is theoretically capable of delivering a higher volumetric energy-density (3833 mAh cm-3) than Li (2061 mAh cm-3). Reports on the advantages of such high energy-density Mg batteries, and interest in the field of new cathodes and electrolytes for Mg batteries have steadily risen.—Singh et al.
Because magnesium is divalent, it can thereby displace double the charge per ion (i.e., Mg2+ rather than Li+). As an element, magnesium is much more abundant than lithium, and more stable. Magnesium-ion batteries theoretically could offer good electrochemical performance, while being safer and less expensive than Li-ion batteries. However, Mg-ion batteries have suffered from a number of limitations, among them being anode/electrolyte incompatibility.
To date, various organohaloaluminates...have been utilized as alternative electrolytes for Mg systems, since conventional battery electrolytes (TFSI-, ClO4-, PF6-) form a Mg2+ blocking layer on the Mg metal anode surface. However, recent reports have shown that these organohaloaluminate electrolytes provide a limited operating voltage window when tested against typical battery current collectors. It is nonetheless possible to develop high voltage Mg systems via the use of conventional battery electrolytes, if the anode system is changed from a Mg metal anode to a Mg-ion insertion-type anode. This change would negate the challenge posed by the Mg2+ blocking layer on the Mg metal anode surface. The use of such insertion-type anodes has been abundant in Li- ion battery technology, where the use of a Li metal anode is deemed impractical, primarily due to dendrite formation.—Singh et al.
The TRINA team had earlier used Bi as a Mg2+ insertion-type anode material, showing it to be compatible with conventional battery electrolytes. However, since high energy-density depends on cell voltage and capacity, they sought to develop next generation Mg-ion battery anode materials which remain compatible with high voltage conventional battery electrolytes, while displaying lower Mg2+ insertion/extraction voltages and higher capacities than Bi.
The TRINA team is now focusing on improving the rate capability of the Sn material and cyclability by exploring advancements in nanomaterials and anode architectures, while identifying and understanding the mechanisms responsible for the material’s poor coulombic efficiency.
Nikhilendra Singh, Timothy S Arthur, Chen Ling, Masaki Matsui and Fuminori Mizuno (2012) A High Energy-Density Tin Anode for Rechargeable Magnesium-ion Batteries. Chem. Commun. doi: 10.1039/C2CC34673G
A. Mitelman, M. D. Levi, E. Lancry, E. Levi and D. Aurbach (2007) New cathode materials for rechargeable Mg batteries: fast Mg ion transport and reversible copper extrusion in CuyMo6S8 compounds. Chem. Commun. 4212-4214 doi: 10.1039/B710743A
Toyota is very serious about post-lithium batteries and will no doubt find ways to produce lower cost more efficient batteries in the near future.
The arrival of many new technologies and Solid States future batteries will make extended range BEVs a reality early in the next decade.
Posted by: HarveyD | 14 November 2012 at 11:29 AM
This news will provoke what. For me it show that actual batteries for cars are subpar costly and weak devises, so im not interrested to buy a plug-in prius, leaf, volt, tesla, imiev, renauld fluence, bmw i3 i4 and i8, via motor truck, toyota rav4, ford c max, any hybrid, portable computer, small battery flashlight, small digital camera, small watchs, chrismas battery toys to give at chrismas, lighthing electric motorcycles, coda cars, byd cars, gasoline car with ac delco or energizer battery.
I prefer to postpone any battery expences till this battery that cost fewer and is 2x the capacity hit the market.
Posted by: Gorr | 14 November 2012 at 11:52 AM
Like you I don't understand the strategy of Toyota , they multiply announcements, solid electrolyte, Mg-ion but ask Tesla to provide them battery and have not shown anything that makes me believe if have something that can give them an advantage on the market when it comes to EV.
Posted by: Treehugger | 14 November 2012 at 02:58 PM
I'm interested in the Renault flatulence. Runs on cow biogas.
Posted by: Mannstein | 14 November 2012 at 04:57 PM
Posted by: SJC | 14 November 2012 at 09:06 PM
Getting the unused 70% value of EV batteries could more than cut costs in half.
Posted by: kelly | 15 November 2012 at 09:34 AM
This has been the idea for years, people put used EV battery packs in their garage for peak shaving, load balancing, distributed generation and UPS.
Posted by: SJC | 15 November 2012 at 10:01 AM
Posted by: chen | 15 November 2012 at 05:23 PM
Manns...you could get more range in Brazil and USA with 200M and 93M cows each.
Posted by: HarveyD | 16 November 2012 at 06:54 AM