Researchers demonstrate high-capacity Mn-rich Li-ion cathodes; a design pathway away from cobalt and nickel
16 April 2018
Researchers led by a team at UC Berkeley have demonstrated high-capacity manganese-rich cathodes for advanced lithium-ion batteries. The work, reported in the journal Nature, shows a possible design approach for cathode materials that move away from the current reliance on nickel and cobalt—which are limited resources and are associated with safety problems. The work was a collaboration between scientists at UC Berkeley, Berkeley Lab, Argonne National Lab, MIT and UC Santa Cruz.
… it is remarkable that almost all Li-ion cathode materials rely on only two transition metals, Ni and Co, which are the electroactive elements in the layered-rocksalt cathode materials in the Li(Ni,Mn,Co)O2 chemical space (NMCs). On one end of this compositional spectrum, LiCoO2 dominates the electronics sector, whereas Ni-rich materials are of interest for the automotive sector. Although Mn [manganese] has been used in a spinel cathode, and Fe in the LiFePO4 olivine, these compounds suffer from low energy density.
Given the limits of energy density that can be achieved with the layered NMCs and the potential resource constraints on cobalt, it is of interest to develop high-capacity cathode materials based on other redox metals. In particular, transition metals that can exchange two electrons are of interest for their ability to create high capacity, similar to the Ni2+/Ni4+ couple in NMC cathodes. Low cost and low toxicity make the Mn2+/Mn4+ couple particularly desirable for designing high-performance Li-ion batteries that are also inexpensive and eco-friendly.
… The development of a high-performance Li-ion cathode based on the Mn2+/Mn4+ couple requires a material that forms in its discharged state, contains enough Mn2+ and Li+ ions to provide high capacity and preferably crystallizes in a dense structure, such as the layered or disordered-rocksalt structure, to maximize its volumetric energy density. Introducing Mn2+ in the dense layered or disordered materials has been difficult, as the Li excess (x > 1 in LixTM2−xO2, where TM is transition metal) required to achieve high practical capacity demands a high average transition metal valence.
In this work, we demonstrate that high capacity (>300 mAh g-1) and energy density (about 1,000 Wh kg−1) can be achieved in disordered-rocksalt Li-rich intercalation cathodes from Mn2+/Mn4+ double redox combined with a small amount of O redox.—Lee et al.
In 2014, the lab of senior author Gerbrand Ceder, professor in the Department of Materials Science and Engineering at Berkeley, discovered a way that cathodes can maintain a high energy density without using the layerered structure of current cathodes—a concept called disordered rock salts. The new study shows how manganese can work within this concept.
To deal with the resource issue of cobalt, you have to go away from this layeredness in cathodes. Disordering cathodes has allowed us to play with a lot more of the periodic table.—Gerbrand Ceder
The new strategy combines high-valent cations and the partial substitution of fluorine for oxygen in a disordered-rocksalt structure to incorporate the reversible Mn2+/Mn4+ double redox couple into lithium-excess cathode materials. The resulting material—Li2Mn2/3Nb1/3O2F—uses the combined presence of high-valent Nb5+ and low-valent F- to set up the charge balance to incorporate Mn as Mn2+, leading to a very high theoretical Mn-redox capacity of 270 mAh g-1—more than twice that of a typical Mn-based Li-rich cathode material.
The team also developed a second new material, Li2Mn1/2Ti1/2O2F, in which Ti4+ is the high-valent cationic species. This material delivers high capacities similar to Li2Mn2/3Nb1/3O2F.
Double redox couples are tremendously important for the development of advanced cathodes. Indeed, today’s modern NMC-based layered cathodes all rely to some extent on the Ni2+/Ni4+ double redox. With Li2Mn2/3Nb1/3O2F and Li2Mn1/2Ti1/2O2F, we have demonstrated that combined fluorination and high-valent cation substitution can introduce Mn2+/Mn4+ redox in a Li-excess disordered-rocksalt structure, which leads to high-capacity Mn-based Li-excess cathodes (capacity of >300 mAh g−1, energy density of around 1,000 Wh kg−1) without an excessive use of O redox. This discovery is important, as our strategy can be widely applied to design high-performance Mn-based Li-excess cathodes that do not suffer from structural degradation triggered by extensive O redox.—Lee et al.
Jinhyuk Lee, Daniil A. Kitchaev, Deok-Hwang Kwon, Chang-Wook Lee, Joseph K. Papp, Yi-Sheng Liu, Zhengyan Lun, Raphaële J. Clément, Tan Shi, Bryan D. McCloskey, Jinghua Guo, Mahalingam Balasubramanian & Gerbrand Ceder (2018) “Reversible Mn2+/Mn4+ double redox in lithium-excess cathode materials” Nature volume 556, pages 185–190 doi: 10.1038/s41586-018-0015-4
LEAF had manganese but they failed to provide thermal management.
Posted by: SJC | 16 April 2018 at 09:05 AM
It seems that, with enough fine tuning, this approach could lead to improved 5X (500 Wh/Kg) batteries required for extended range BEVs?
Will/could mass produced units become available by 2025 and affordable for extended range BEVs with 150 to 200 kWh battery pack?
Posted by: HarveyD | 16 April 2018 at 09:09 AM
In the real world, the Leaf MnLi batteries haven't proved their ability to sustain a long life and to maintain density over time. The 2011 Leaf 24kW battery spec was about 140 Wh/kg; however, Nissan claims about 240 Wh/kg for their newly announced 40 kW pac. But, many believe this was achieved with a change of chemistry and a new manufacturer, L. G. Chem.
Posted by: Lad | 16 April 2018 at 12:34 PM
Reports are the 30 kWh packs have even worse degradation than the 24 kWh packs.
Posted by: SJC | 17 April 2018 at 07:45 AM
Based on all the comments regarding the Nissan Leaf LiMn batteries, the article in Supplementary Note 3 states "Most of the Li-excess Mn-rich cathodes using high levels of oxygen redox experience voltage fading, a continuous reduction of both
charge and discharge voltages upon extended cycling10,57. From the evolution of
average voltages upon cycling (Extended Data Fig. 6), we find that voltage fading
for Li2Mn2/3Nb1/3O2F is less pronounced than for other Mn-rich cathodes. "
Posted by: Account Deleted | 17 April 2018 at 12:29 PM