Study finds particulates from auxiliary vehicle heaters can be up to 1000 times higher than from idling gasoline engines
Researchers from Tampere University and the University of Eastern Finland have found that the particulate emissions of auxiliary heaters can be up to a thousand times higher than the particulate emissions of idling gasoline vehicles. Their open-access study is published in the journal Atmosphere.
Auxiliary heaters, sold under such well-known brand names as Webasto and Eberspächer, among others, are used in both passenger cars and heavy-duty vehicles to preheat the engine and provide additional cabin heating while driving. Emissions from heaters are not regulated, although they are widely used in especially colder regions, such as Finland. Therefore, they can have a significant impact on local air quality, and even on regional or global emissions budgets.
The research team studied the emissions of eight selected vehicles equipped with an additional heater, either diesel or gasoline, depending on the car’s propulsion power. Tests were carried out in collaboration with Dekati Ltd.
Average particle number concentrations measured from the vehicle exhaust during engine idling and from the auxiliary heater exhaust during its operation. Averages are calculated from both the plateau period as well as from the full range of operation (20 min cycle including the startup and shutdown of the heater). Count median diameters of the particle size distributions measured with the HR-ELPI+ and the CPC overrange limits are presented as well. CPC data were not available for two car idle measurements, these are indicated in the figure with a red “X”. ePNC overrange limit is indicated with a dark blue arrow. Karjalainen et al.
The results of the study raise the question of whether the use of heaters is justified with regard to the objective of reducing overall vehicle emissions. In addition, auxiliary fuel-fired heaters have been proposed as a solution for heating the cabin of electric vehicles so that it does not consume power from the battery, which in turn shortens the distance that a vehicle can drive on a single charge.
The researchers found that both gasoline and diesel heaters produced the highest particle concentrations immediately after start-up and shutdown. During the steady heating period, the particulate concentration in the emission remained at a constant level, which, however, was significantly higher than the emission from the idling of the car.
In particular, in the case of diesel engines complying with the Euro 5b emission standard, all of which are equipped with a diesel particulate filter, emissions from auxiliary heaters are emphasized in relation to the very low particulate concentrations in the exhaust pipes.
However, Senior Researcher Santtu Mikkonen from the University of Eastern Finland points out that the study does not take a position on the effect of additional heaters on engine cold-start emissions or the reduction of engine wear. Therefore, more research is needed to better investigate emissions and their environmental impact, and to make recommendations on the use and development of heaters.
Karjalainen, Panu, Markus Nikka, Miska Olin, Sampsa Martikainen, Antti Rostedt, Anssi Arffman, and Santtu Mikkonen (2021) “Fuel-Operated Auxiliary Heaters Are a Major Additional Source of Vehicular Particulate Emissions in Cold Regions” Atmosphere 12, no. 9: 1105. doi: 10.3390/atmos12091105